Illegal immigration is flash point for Republican White House hopefuls
By Philip Rucker
and and Amy Gardner, Friday, September 2, 2011
KEENE, N.H. — Mitt Romney opened his
town hall meeting here talking about the economy — his thoughts on growing
business, getting government out of the way — just as he does nearly every other
campaign event. But when he opened last weekfs forum for questions, the first
voter he called on didnft seem concerned about any of that. He wanted to know
the Republican presidential candidatefs stance on border security.
A similar scene played out in South Carolina a few days later, when Rep.
Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.) attended
a town hall meeting she assumed would center on the economy, jobs and the
federal deficit — only to see the assembled voters react most passionately to
her comments on illegal immigration.
Polls may not suggest it, and the candidates may not be catering to it, but
immigration is an issue that voters wonft let the GOP White House hopefuls
escape.
Republican primary voters keep bringing immigration up as the candidates
campaign in back yards, opera houses and recreation halls across Iowa, New
Hampshire and South Carolina. To a sizable chunk of those who will pick the
GOPfs presidential nominee, immigration is an urgent issue, even a litmus
test.
gImmigration is not even close to the top issue for most Republicans today,
but it is an issue that is heavy with symbolic importance to Republican voters,h
said GOP pollster Jon Lerner, who advised Tim Pawlenty until he
dropped out of the race last month. gIf a candidate is squishy on
immigration, that symbolically suggests that hefs probably unreliable on a whole
host of other conservative issues.h
The view in the Republican Party on immigration has shifted dramatically to
the right since 2006, when President George W. Bush proposed an overhaul that
would have combined a legalization plan with tighter border security.
The issue is likely to take on even greater significance in the race for the
Republican nomination with the recent entrance of Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who
oversees the nationfs biggest border state and who has a longer and more
complicated record on immigration than his opponents.
Since entering the race, Perry has taken a tough stance on the issue.
gOnce we secure the border, we can have a conversation about immigration
reform in this country, but not until,h Perry
told reporters after a campaign stop last month in South Carolina. gYou must
have the federal government putting the resources, the boots on the ground, the
aviation assets in the air, and secure that border so that we know that the
border is secure before we have a conversation about any immigration
reform.h
Perryfs history with the border is more nuanced than that. He has long
advocated a more seamless border between his state and Mexico, and he has
traveled there to drum up business for his state. In 2007, he called the
proposed construction of a fence between the United States and Mexico gidiocy,h
saying git absolutely would not work.h
Ray Sullivan, Perryfs communications director, said that remains Perryfs
position.
gFencing a 2,000-mile border is not practical,h Sullivan said. gThe governor
does and has always supported what he calls estrategic fencingf in urban and
high-trafficked areas.h
During Perryfs first year in office, he signed a law allowing any student who
has lived in Texas for three years and graduates from a Texas high school to pay
in-state tuition at state colleges, regardless of their citizenship status.
The bill passed with overwhelming bipartisan support but now is criticized by
some Republicans as a precursor to the federal DREAM Act, a Democratic proposal
to create a path to citizenship for some illegal immigrants brought into the
country as children.
Last year, Perry criticized Arizonafs tough new immigration enforcement law,
saying that it gwould not be the right direction for Texas.h
Sullivan said Perryfs stances made sense for Texas, pointing out that many
Texans have economic, cultural and family ties across the border. gTexans have a
very close and perhaps unique perspective on border issues,h he said.
Some conservatives have begun attacking Perry on immigration. gHefs just a
little bit too much like George Bush,h Ann Coulter recently said on Fox
News.
On immigration, Romneyfs position is to secure the border before considering
comprehensive reform. At the town hall in Keene, he said that means to gturn off
the magnet.h
gEmployers in the U.S. who knowingly hire people who are here illegally —
thatfs the magnet,h he said. gSo we have to crack down on employers that hire
illegals, make it easy for them to determine whofs here legally and whofs not,
and then crack down on those who hire illegals.h
Bachmann, too, wants to crack down on those who are in the United States
illegally. On a recent
five-day campaign swing, she was asked about immigration at virtually every
stop. At one, a town hall meeting in
North Charleston, S.C., she elicited the most passionate response of the evening
when she took a question on immigration.
Bachmann promised to build a fence along gevery mile, every yard, every foot,
every inchh of the nationfs southern border, to ghave the backh of enforcement
agents, and to put an end to the provision of federal benefits to illegal
immigrants.
But she really got her audience going with a series of lamentations about the
border that places her to the right of her opponents.
gOn the southern border, we are dealing with a narco-terrorist state today in
Mexico,h Bachmann said. gBecause 70 percent of narcotics are coming to the
United States are coming from Mexico. Mexico is in a very different place right
now. We are seeing criminals, felons, drugs, wefre seeing contagious diseases
coming into our country. What is wrong with our government that it isnft
stopping this from coming into the nation?h
The applause was loud, yet the man who asked the question, Rich Wiedenhoft,
left unsatisfied.
gThe very town I live in is a sanctuary city, and Ifm very ashamed of that,h
Wiedenhoft, 63, an Air Force retiree, said later in an interview. gI served in
the military for 20 years defending the flag. And I resent people coming in here
and taking advantage of us. I consider them invaders.h
So which candidate might appeal more than Bachmann?
gThat,h he said, gis what I keep going to these meetings to find out.h
Staff researcher Alice Crites and polling director Jon Cohen contributed to
this report. Gardner reported from South Carolina.
© The Washington Post Company